Skip to content
Swiss Observer

Zurich hospital makes first compensation payments over heart surgery scandal

Zurich University Hospital has paid compensation in 14 cases connected to its heart surgery scandal, with 20 claims received so far. The hospital says it has reached out-of-court settlements with all claimants; several claims remain pending.

AINovember 19, 2026About our editorial process
Zurich hospital makes first compensation payments over heart surgery scandal
AISWI swissinfo.ch

Zurich University Hospital has begun paying compensation to people affected by its heart surgery scandal, including surviving relatives. USZ says it has paid compensation in 14 cases and received 20 claims in total.

The hospital said the combined payout is in the low six-figure range. It has reached out-of-court settlements with claimants, while several claims remain pending. No legal proceedings have been initiated in the compensation cases.

The payments follow a scandal involving the hospital’s cardiac surgery clinic and its former head, Francesco Maisano. The case drew attention to outcomes in thousands of operations at the Zurich hospital. USZ’s first payments establish a route for compensation outside the courts as prosecutors continue to investigate separate allegations tied to the scandal.

Track the Claims and Settlements

USZ says it has settled claims out of court, with compensation reaching affected patients and surviving relatives in 14 cases. The hospital has received 20 claims, and several remain pending.

The distinction between the claims received and the cases compensated reflects a process that is still under way. USZ says it has reached out-of-court settlements with claimants, and no legal proceedings have been initiated in any of the compensation cases. The total amount to be paid falls in the low six-figure range.

The arrangements address compensation claims connected to the scandal. They are separate from the criminal investigations being handled by Zurich’s public prosecutor’s office. Those investigations concern suspected offences, while the compensation process has so far proceeded through settlements rather than court cases.

Measure the Scale of the Scandal

The scandal concerns around 4,500 heart operations at USZ, with between 68 and 74 more deaths than statistically expected reported. The people represented by that difference might still be alive if they had undergone surgery at another hospital, according to the report.

The scandal surrounding Francesco Maisano, the former head of the hospital’s cardiac surgery clinic, first broke in May. The reported excess deaths place the compensation claims against a broader record of surgical outcomes at the hospital.

The figures describe deaths above a statistical expectation across the operations. They do not identify every patient or establish that each individual death resulted from a particular decision. The claims process and the continuing investigations are addressing cases linked to the scandal through separate channels.

Follow the Prosecutors’ Investigation

Zurich prosecutors are investigating three cases on suspicion of manslaughter, causing grievous bodily harm through negligence and forgery of documents. The public prosecutor’s office has also received 11 reports concerning the inappropriate use of medical devices.

The allegations include that Maisano used the Cardioband, a product he helped develop, even when it was often not the right choice. He is also alleged to have personally benefited financially from its use. These remain allegations under investigation.

The compensation settlements have not initiated legal proceedings in those cases, according to USZ. The prosecutor’s work continues on a separate track, examining suspected criminal offences and reports about device use. For patients and relatives with claims still pending, the hospital’s compensation process remains active alongside those investigations.